Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /home/customer/www/ on line 37
2004 Judicial Election -

E-Democracy Pages Wiki

Search Wiki




2004 Judicial Election


Revision as of 14:57, 30 July 2012 by JohnColeman (Talk | contribs) (minor updates)

Back To: Citizens Guide to St. Paul

Summary of Oct 2004 discussion about Judicial Elections

This is a summary of a discussion that took place in the St. Paul Issues Forum, in October 2004. Written and posted by, Tim Erickson.

John Birrenbach initially posted his endorsement of Patricia Sifferle and reminded us that Judicial races are often uncontested. He suggested that this was not good for democracy and that we ought to encourage more competition for these judicial offices.

Andy Driscoll posted an alternative endorsement for the incumbent Mike Fetsch along with the following statement:

  "It is customary, especially for nonpartisan
   seats on the District Court, that challengers
   to an incumbent judge standing for reelection
   (or election, if appointed) present cogent
   reasons for doing so, and I challenge Ms.
   Sifferle to state those reasons."

Joelle Tegwen agreed with John that "we definitely need to work to make contested judicial races more common and learn more about the judges who are appointed." However, she expressed her disappointment with the answers Patricia Sifferle provided on the Minnesota Lawyer questionnaire. See Second District - Seat 14

Charlie Swope agreed that as long as we are having judicial elections, it makes sense to have them contested. However, he questioned the idea of having judicial elections at all and suggests that his own preference would be for an appointed judiciary.

Patricia Sifferle joined the discussion and briefly discussed her reasons for running and responded directly to the questions raised by Joelle Tegwen. Her full message can be read here:

   - "I believe I will be a better judge."
   - "I have pledged not to do any negative
  "I am running strictly on my merits to serve, and
  because I would like to improve on the way things
  are currently being done.  I believe I am more
  approachable, articulate, down-to-earth, courteous,
  energetic, kind, and diplomatic than my opponent,
  and I will make an excellent judge for Ramsey County.
  I hope you will vote for me on November 2nd."

Bill Stoesz pointed out that the MCCL is running stealth campaigns in some parts of the state to replace incumbent judges with single-issue judges compatible on their issue. He questioned whether or not Patricia Sifferle might not be one of those candidates. Patricia Sifferle responded - "I am absolutely not one of these candidates!" She went on to say that she does not believe that judicial candidates should affiliate themselves with any interest organizations and should not accept party endorsements.

Jeanne Weigum posted a story about a case that she was involved in before incumbent judge Mike Fetsch. She expressed her displeasure with his handling of the case and stated that she "will not be voting for Judge Fetsch."

Tom Goldstein expressed his confidence in Jeanne Weigum's opinions and the added fact that Patricia Sifferle is a "Carleton grad, which means she's gotta have something on the ball!"

Anne Carroll posted comments which suggest caution in making voting decisions based upon one experience or event. She goes on to raise interesting questions about how we make choices that affect who we support or choose not to support in an election.

Brian Bates takes us back to the question of choosing judges by election vs. appointment. He expresses frustration at the manner in which judges have subverted the constitutional process, by making it a practice to leave office mid-term so that their successor can be appointed. He suggests that we elect judges or that we change our constitution and appoint them, but that we not continue this practice of midterm appointments to prevent genuine contested judicial elections.

White dress, green wedding

Lindsey Gehl and Ryan Bell have a vision of their June wedding being white - and green, too.The 27-year-olds will pledge their troth in a traditional ceremony, followed by a reception amid the scenic trails and wildlife habitats of the Pilcher Park Nature Center in Joliet, Illinois, to which theyre donating $600.

[White dress, green wedding]

[ - good, positive news, inspirational stories, articles]

Starting A Slow Story Movement

"It is said that we become the stories that we tell among ourselves. This might have been true before we became salespersons. For a few decades now, I think we have become numb to the stories that we tell among ourselves. So stories have become shorter and crisper to the length of a tweet. We are so committed to telling a story to the point that finally what remains is a dimensionless point.

[Starting A Slow Story Movement]

[ - good, positive news, inspirational stories, articles]

Awakening Our Collaborative Spirit

The physicist, David Bohm, while researching the lives of Einstein, Heisenberg, Pauli and Bohr, made a remarkable observation. Bohm noticed that their incredible breakthroughs took place through simple, open and honest conversation. He observed, for instance, that Einstein and his colleagues spent years freely meeting and conversing with each other.

[Awakening Our Collaborative Spirit]

[ - good, positive news, inspirational stories, articles]

New Toilet System Transform Waste into Electricity

Scientists from Nanyang Technological University (NTU) have invented a new toilet system that will turn human waste into electricity and fertilisers and also reduce the amount of water needed for flushing by up to 90 per cent compared to current toilet systems in Singapore.

[New Toilet System Transform Waste into Electricity]

[ - good, positive news, inspirational stories, articles]

Three Qualifications for the New Politician

There are plenty of politicians who genuinely desire to serve their communities and nations with humility and integrity, dedicating their lives to the cultivation of a wisdom that will benefit society at large; sadly, they are a minority.

[Three Qualifications for the New Politician]

[ - good, positive news, inspirational stories, articles]


Home - Mobile - Forums - Wiki - Blog - About - Help - Contact - People - Donate - Rules - Archives